Key takeaways
- AthenaHQ has a free Essential tier and a $295/mo Starter plan (per a third-party summary of its pricing page), with nothing published in between. Agencies running 5 to 20 clients feel that gap quickly.
- The real agency questions are isolated client workspaces, seats, white-label reporting, and what the tool does after it finds a gap. Headline price matters less.
- Credits, flat prompt allowances and per-engine metering are not comparable. Compare cost per tracked prompt per engine.
- Promptwatch, Peec AI, Profound and Scrunch are the strongest options built with agencies in mind. Otterly and Trakkr are cheaper if you only need monitoring.
- Verify every price on the vendor's own page before you sign. These numbers change often.
Why agencies outgrow AthenaHQ
AthenaHQ is a decent product. It has an Action Center that turns citation data into prioritized recommendations, an Ask Athena natural-language interface, and Search Console, Shopify and Google Analytics integrations. Self-serve plans include unlimited seats, which agencies like.
The friction is elsewhere. According to Rework's comparison (which cites athenahq.ai/pricing, and which I have not independently checked), the Essential plan is free with a one-time $25 credit (300 credits). Starter is $295/mo on the monthly toggle with 3,600 credits and 11+ platforms. One credit is one AI response, so you are paying about $0.08 per response. Enterprise is custom with a demo required.
Now do the agency math. Ten clients, 30 prompts each, five engines, tracked daily. That is 1,500 responses per day, and a credit pool measured in thousands per month evaporates in a couple of days. Omnia's write-up makes a similar point: credit limits on Self-Serve can constrain high-volume prompt testing, and the deeper citation features sit behind Enterprise pricing.

So "independent" for an agency really means three things: you control client separation, you control the reporting that reaches clients, and pricing does not scale linearly with every prompt you add.
What to check before you switch
Ranketta's agency guide lists criteria worth borrowing, though note it ranks itself first, so treat its rankings with salt. The criteria themselves are sensible:
- Isolated client workspaces, so one client's data never leaks into another's.
- Access controls and seats, ideally unlimited.
- How many client sites a plan covers.
- White-label or at least brandable reports.
- What the tool does after a finding: report it, recommend a fix, write content, or publish.
If a platform has no native white-label output, you need a reporting pipe you control: Looker Studio or an API feeding your own client dashboard.
Engine coverage per client
For most consumer brands, track ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini and Perplexity at minimum. Report each engine separately. Promptwatch Data on average sources per response shows why: ChatGPT cites about 5 sources per web-search answer, Google AI Overviews about 10, and Perplexity almost exactly 10 every day, while Copilot swung from under 2 to nearly 17 within weeks. One blended number hides all of that.
Re-audit prompts, too
Agencies often set prompts once and forget them. Promptwatch's ChatGPT query fanout data shows average query length falling from about 117 characters to roughly 53 between late 2025 and spring 2026, and searches per response shifting too. A prompt set that made sense in January may be stale by now, so choose a tool that makes prompt review easy across a whole roster.
Compare cost per tracked prompt per engine
Rework flags the classic pitfall: vendors meter differently (flat prompts, credits per response, credits per engine), and cheap entry tiers often cover fewer engines. A $29 plan that tracks four engines for a handful of prompts is not comparable to a $245 plan with unlimited projects.
The shortlist at a glance
| Tool | Starting price (verify on vendor site) | Agency setup | What it does after a finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Promptwatch | Agency Kick-off $199/mo, Growth $399/mo, Scale $799/mo | Unlimited projects, prompts and seats; pitch projects | Action Board, Agent Chat, crawler logs, visitor analytics |
| Peec AI | Starter $95/mo, agency plans from $245/mo | Unlimited users, pitch projects, partner program | Scored recommendations; no content writing |
| Profound | Free trial, custom Enterprise | Agency Mode with isolated workspaces | Monitoring plus analytics, enterprise focus |
| Scrunch AI | Starter $300/mo; nothing under $250/mo | Partner program, up to 20% commission | Monitoring plus agent-ready pages |
| Otterly.AI | Lite $29/mo, real tracking tier $189/mo | Lightweight | Monitoring |
| Trakkr | Growth $100/mo, all 8 models | Per-brand prompts | Visitor-to-revenue tracing |
| Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit | $99/mo per domain (annual) | Per-domain pricing | SEO suite integration |
Promptwatch: the one built to act, not just report
Full disclosure: Promptwatch is the platform 1001 SEO Media, which publishes this site, uses for its own GEO work. I would still tell you the same thing if I were writing for a stranger, because the agency plans are the cleanest fit for the problem in this guide.

The agency tiers (Kick-off $199/mo, Growth $399/mo, Scale $799/mo, always confirm at promptwatch.com/pricing) give you unlimited projects, prompts and team seats, all AI models, country, state and city tracking, Brand Narrative, Ads Radar, crawler logs, visitor analytics, site audits, content gap analysis, custom reports, and MCP and API access. That solves the credit-metering anxiety: you do not ration prompts per client. Responses are capped per plan (10,000, 25,000 and 65,000 respectively), so cost per response still matters, and Promptwatch is among the lowest on that metric.
Where it separates from monitoring-only tools:
- Data comes from the real interfaces of ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Copilot, Meta AI and Alexa, per country and language, not just API outputs.
- IP-verified AI crawler logs show whether bots can even read a client's pages, which separates an access problem from a content problem. Most competitors lack this entirely.
- Visitor analytics close the loop: does AI traffic convert? Monks, one of the larger agency users, built client content roadmaps from the Answer Gap Report.
- Agent Chat can build dashboards and PDF reports on request, and scheduled PDF reports go to client inboxes. White-label PDF export with your own branding and a white-label client portal sit on Enterprise, which is the main caveat for agencies.
- The Action Board gives each project a prioritized to-do list, with assignees and comments.
The honest limits: agency plans do not include the Content Agent, AEO articles, the Knowledge Base, or ChatGPT Shopping. Agencies that want content generation inside the tool need Enterprise. See Promptwatch's agency page and the GEO for agencies guide. There is a 7-day free trial on monthly billing, and the free AI visibility report is a decent pitch asset for a prospect.
Peec AI: strong pure monitoring
Peec AI is the usual name that comes up for pure multi-client monitoring. Per Rework, Starter is $95/mo and agency plans start at $245/mo, with unlimited users on every tier. Self-serve tiers pick three engines, and Perplexity is a paid add-on. Ranketta adds that agency plans are credit-based, with pitch projects and an Agency Partner Program, and that a single brand plan stretches to roughly three clients.
It tracks product-level results in ChatGPT Shopping, Gemini, Perplexity and AI Overviews, and gives scored recommendations, but it does not write or publish content. If your agency has its own content team and wants a clean monitoring layer, it is a sane pick. Compare directly: Promptwatch vs Peec.
Profound: enterprise rosters
Profound has no self-serve paid tier; you get a free trial and then custom Enterprise pricing. Ranketta says its Agency Mode gives every client an isolated workspace and tracks up to nine answer engines on Enterprise. That is the best isolation story in the list on paper, but you are negotiating a contract rather than swiping a card. See Promptwatch vs Profound.
Scrunch AI: partner-friendly, pricey entry
Scrunch Starter is $300/mo per Rework, with nothing under $250/mo, covering seven platforms including Meta, and the company is now owned by Sitecore. Ranketta notes up to 20% commission on referred customers and a free prospecting license for pitches, which matters if you want to resell. It also builds agent-ready pages for your site. Compare via Promptwatch vs Scrunch.

Cheaper options if you only need monitoring
Otterly.AI
Lite is $29/mo and covers four core engines, but Rework says the real tracking tier is $189/mo. Fine for small rosters, thin for deeper analysis.

Trakkr
Growth is $100/mo with all eight models included, but base plans cover 50 prompts per brand and extra prompts cost more. It also traces AI visitors to revenue. Check its 14-day trial claim on its own site.
Rankscale
From $20/mo billed annually, but credits are weighted per engine and the entry tier ships with zero credits. Read the metering before you get excited.
SEO suites with AI add-ons
If a client already lives in one of these, the add-on may be enough.
- Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit is $99/mo per domain billed annually, with 25 prompts and each extra 50 at $60/mo. Per-domain pricing multiplies fast across a roster.
- Ahrefs Brand Radar is free on Lite and above, with Custom Prompts from $50/mo.
- HubSpot AEO is $50/mo ($45 annual), no HubSpot subscription required, three engines, no AI Overviews.
- BrightEdge and Conductor target enterprise SEO teams, with Conductor's pricing unpublished.


They are fixed-prompt, shallow on AI-specific data, and none give crawler logs. Good as a bolt-on, rarely as the main system. For wider shopping, the GEO software directory at bestgeosoftware.com lists dozens more.

Which should you pick?
| Your situation | Likely fit |
|---|---|
| 5+ clients, want unlimited prompts and projects, crawler logs and traffic attribution | Promptwatch Growth or Scale |
| Own content team, only need clean multi-client monitoring | Peec AI |
| Enterprise roster, procurement is fine with a sales cycle | Profound |
| Want a resale or referral program | Scrunch AI |
| 1 to 3 small clients, tight budget | Otterly.AI or Trakkr |
| Clients already deep in Semrush or Ahrefs | Add-on toolkits plus a dedicated tracker |
A simple evaluation process
- Pick two representative clients, one with a big brand and one small or local.
- Load 20 to 30 real prompts each, across at least ChatGPT, AI Overviews and Perplexity.
- Run two weeks and compare how many responses each tool actually gives you per dollar.
- Build one client report end to end. If it takes more than an hour, the reporting pipe is the problem.
- Ask each vendor what happens when you add client number eleven.
A note on vendor bias
Most comparison articles in this space are written by vendors. Ranketta ranks itself first, SearchEye calls AthenaHQ "the strongest independent alternative" while selling its own product, and Rework is more neutral but still summarizes pricing pages secondhand. Use all of them for pointers, then check primary sources. The full Promptwatch comparison of GEO platforms is vendor-written too, so apply the same skepticism. For a broader ranking of trackers, see ai-rank-tools.com.
One last practical point: whichever tool you choose, test whether it can export data into your own reporting layer. Agencies that own the client dashboard can swap trackers later without losing the relationship.




